Washington, D.C. – In a heated courtroom exchange, Federal Judge James Boasberg sharply criticized former President Donald Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act, warning it could have "frightening implications" for civil liberties and immigration law in the United States.
The Alien Enemies Act, dating back to 1798, allows the president to detain or restrict non-citizens from nations deemed hostile. Trump’s legal team has cited the law to justify mass deportation plans targeting certain immigrant groups, sparking outrage and legal challenges.
Judge Boasberg Raises Red Flags
During the latest hearing, Judge Boasberg stated:
"This approach sets a troubling precedent. Using a centuries-old law to justify modern mass deportations could open the door to abuse of executive power in future crises."
Legal experts echoed concerns, saying the law was never meant for broad immigration enforcement, especially in peacetime.
Trump’s Defense
Trump's attorneys argued that the law allows for swift national security measures, especially since the U.S. is facing rising geopolitical threats. They claim the Act gives the President broad authority in times of national emergency to act against individuals from “enemy nations.”
However, critics say the vague definition of ‘enemy’ nations could be manipulated, putting millions of lawful residents at risk.
Civil Rights Concerns
Immigration advocacy groups warned that targeting individuals based on nationality or origin could violate constitutional protections, and lead to racial profiling.
“This opens the door to mass detentions and deportations without due process,” said a civil liberties lawyer present at the hearing. “The consequences for immigrant communities could be devastating.”
What Happens Next?
The judge has not issued a final ruling but signaled that further hearings and legal scrutiny are expected. Meanwhile, public protests and political debate over immigration policies are intensifying across the U.S.
As the 2024 election cycle heats up, Trump’s legal moves are closely watched, with immigration expected to be a central campaign issue.